Apr 22 2008
ESSAY which has to do with pictures!
One painting is by John Singer Sargeant and is called The Black Brook. The other is a children’s portrait and it by Julie Gearan. These two paintings have similar subjects, young girls, but they however have a very different feel and connotation to the painting. These different connotations originate from the artists themselves and the environment that both artists were in at the time.
John Singer Sargent was born in on January 12, 1856 in Florence, Italy to an American family. Sargent studied all around Europe and finally settled in Paris to study under Carolus-Duran. He was very talented at painting portraits and landscapes in oil paints and watercolors.
Eventually, Sargent became very popular in Paris and many of his paintings were exhibited in the Salon. After the painting Madam X created a scandal in Paris, Sargent was forced to move to London in order to escape the criticism in Paris.
Sargent never married or had any children so he was very close the one of his nieces named Rose Marie who had become a widow in 1914 when her husband died in WWI. Rose Marie was Sargent’s favorite model, and painted her often. In 1908 the painting The Brook, Rose Marie is the girl who is portrayed. Many years after the painting was finished, Rose Marie was killed by a German bomb while attending a Good Friday service in church.
Because of the tragedy that arose from the life of his neice Rose Marie, the painting reflects these feelings. When first looking at the painting, one can see that it is a painting of a warm sunny day in the countryside, it is aesthetically pleasing, and one’s eye is drawn to the young girl sitting by the brook. When the painting is examined more closely one can see that there is a shadow on this sunny day, and this shadow is cast on the girls upper body. The girl’s legs and hand are in the light, and her dress is painted in light hues, similar to the rest of the painting that is in the light. The girl’s upper body is painted in cool tones, and then everything else in the painting that is in shadow is in black or browns. The contrasting colors on the girl give the painting a deeper meaning. It says while everything seems to be bright and nice, there is a darkness that the girl is feeling. Also, the girl’s line of vision is somewhat towards the brook. She looks at the water wistful expression as if she is pining for someone. The darkness of the brook along with the shadow on the girl gives the observer an idea that she really is pining. These two contrasting colors and values along with the detail of the girl shows that the emphasis is on her in the painting, and what she is feeling. Because the girl is light and the brook is dark, the observer can make the conclusion that what the girl is thinking of is dark. Because of this, the imagery that this painting gives off is that the girl is feeling sadness.
Julie Gearan is an artist of our time. She lived in Chicago, but when she wanted a better and happier childhood for her children she moved to a more inviting place the raise them. Here she paints her children and various portraits along with murals. Painting wall murals is her main job, but currently she is trying to get her portfolio of portraits together.
As a mother of several children Julie Gearan wanted to paint portraits of her happy children. In this painting of the young girl she seems to have an opposite effect that John Singer Sergeant’s painting of his niece had. The painting shows lighter hues on the girl and darker ones on the background which makes the viewers eyes travel directly to the girl and stay focused on the girl. Also the girl is exactly in the middle of the painting which further suggested that she is what is meant to be seen and looked at first. The girls reflection is rosy and she is dressed in a white shift. This white shift shows that she still has to innocence of childhood. The look on her face is tranquil but it can be seen that she is happy and refined. This is the exact opposite of Rose Marie in the Black Brook. This child is happy and Rose Marie was rightly mourning.
Both these painting are of young women, but how the artist uses different color tones shows the readers a different connotation. The shadow in the child’s portrait enhances the happiness seen in the child, whereas the shadow dashed across Rose Marie shows the sorrow. Both these paintings are of portraits but the artist style from the artists allows the viewers to see the meaning.
The Black Brook

Children’s Portrait
